---
title: "How NUNA compares: NUNA"
description: "How a self-healing radio mesh compares with a satellite terminal at every station, consumer LoRa meshes and LoRaWAN gateways, and how to add NUNA to a station you already run."
url: https://howitworks.nunasystems.com/compare
---

Why NUNA

There are a few common ways to get data home from a remote site, and each works well somewhere. We designed NUNA for one case in particular: a whole Arctic field site that runs unattended through winter. Here is where we fit, and how the options compare.

Where each option fits Qualitative

Where it fits

### Satellite reaches everywhere, one station at a time

A terminal at every station means its own power supply, its own airtime and its own visit when it fails.

### Consumer meshes are made for people, not stations

Their batteries are built to be recharged within weeks, and they are not rated for an Arctic winter.

### We built for the remote, low-power corner

Scheduled radios, power-aware routing and a self-healing mesh, tested in a climate chamber to -40°C.

Your options

Six things station operators told us they weigh up, set against each other two at a time. On every map, up and to the right is better. Where another option is the better fit, the map shows it.

Cold against delivery Qualitative

Cold and delivery measured

### Through a winter nobody visits

An unattended site has to survive the cold and keep delivering when something fails. Our V1 boards were tested to -40°C in a climate chamber at DTU, and the mesh reroutes around a node that drops out. A satellite link is reliable too, but a station with one terminal has one point of failure.

Reach against running cost Qualitative

Reach and running cost target

### One uplink for a whole site

A satellite terminal serves the station it stands at, with airtime paid every month. A LoRaWAN gateway covers its own cell and needs power and backhaul in each one. A consumer mesh costs least to buy, if you build and maintain it yourself. Serving a whole site from one uplink is a V2 design target.

Bandwidth against power Qualitative

Bandwidth and power target

### Where a terminal is the better fit

If a station needs to send images, a satellite terminal is the right tool, and it needs the power to match. We carry sensor readings, on nodes designed to run 2 to 5 years on a battery. That battery life is a V2 design target. Carrying readings at very low power is the case we designed for.

Show the ratings as a table Criterion NUNA Satellite terminal Consumer LoRa mesh LoRaWAN gateways How you pay Service subscription replace and repair Terminal and airtime per station, every month Low hardware cost you build and maintain it Gateway per cell plus power and backhaul Power Ultra low 2 to 5 year battery target High terminal and heater Medium recharged within weeks Low at the sensor gateway needs steady power Coverage A whole remote site 5 to 15 km per hop target Anywhere with sky one terminal per station Local areas short hops One cell per gateway backhaul in every cell Cold -40°C climate chamber at DTU measured Cold capable heating draws power Consumer grade battery cold limits Industrial rating varies Delivery Self-healing mesh reroutes on its own Reliable link one terminal, one point of failure Best effort messages flooded Acknowledged no relaying between sensors Bandwidth Low sensor readings, not video High enough for images Low short messages Low small payloads

Positions are qualitative, drawn from vendor documentation and conversations with station operators. NUNA values marked as a design target are modelled for the V2 node and have not been validated in the field. The first field deployment is planned for summer 2027.

Getting started

Switching does not mean starting over. If a station already has a satellite terminal, the mesh grows out from it, and the sensors already on site plug into our nodes. If there is nothing on site yet, we supply every part of the network.

You have a station Keep your satellite terminal. Our gateway uses it as the uplink and the nodes form a mesh behind it. Start with ten nodes and add more as the site grows.

Your sensors plug in The sensor ports are Phoenix Contact headers, and more than 100 Phoenix Contact connector types fit them. The instruments and cables a station already runs connect with the right plug, not a replacement.

You have nothing yet We supply the whole network: a gateway with its uplink, relays and sensor nodes, all one board set configured by firmware.

Room to grow A full network is designed to cover about 31,000 km². That is a V2 design target, not yet validated in the field.

Extending a station

One terminal, extended into a whole site

Measured and targeted

We keep the two apart. Measured values come from the climate chamber at DTU. Design targets are modelled for the V2 node, and each one will be replaced by a measurement once it has been observed in the field.

![Three V1 circuit boards with an antenna on a board inside a frosted climate chamber](https://howitworks.nunasystems.com/assets/photos/v1-climate-chamber.jpg)

_V1 boards inside the climate chamber at DTU during cold testing_

measured In the climate chamber

In a climate chamber at DTU tested to minus 40 degrees Celsius
Of about 19,600 packets acknowledged at -40°C over 98 percent
Crystal clock stability held to 0.03 parts per million

target V2 design targets, modelled

Battery life per node Target 2 to 5years
Distance per hop, depending on terrain Target 5 to 15km
Area one network is designed to cover Target ~31,000km²

If you run an Arctic station or a monitoring programme, we would like to hear what you need to measure and where. Or follow the build, with occasional updates on the first field season.

This page has a form, which works in a browser. You can also write to contact@nunasystems.com.

We use your address to send occasional updates. You can unsubscribe from any email. See our [privacy page](https://nunasystems.com/privacy).

[Or write to us directly](https://nunasystems.com/contact)

---

NUNA, DTU Skylab, Lyngby, Denmark. contact@nunasystems.com
